- 1953: Bernie Faloney, B, Maryland
- 1954: Jerry Barger, B, Duke
- 1955: Bob Pellegrini, C, Maryland
- 1956: Bill Barnes, B, Wake Forest
- 1957: Dick Christy, B, NC State
- 1958: Alex Hawkins, E, South Carolina
- 1959: Mike McGee, G, Duke
- 1960: Roman Gabriel, QB, NC State
- 1961: Roman Gabriel, QB, NC State
- 1962: Billy Gambrell, B, South Carolina
- 1963: Jay Wilkinson, B, Duke
- 1964: Brian Piccolo, B, Wake Forest
- 1965: Danny Talbott, B, North Carolina
- 1966: Bob Davis, B, Virginia
- 1967: Buddy Gore, B, Clemson
- 1968: Frank Quayle, B, Virginia
- 1969: Don McCauley, B, North Carolina
- 1970: Don McCauley, B, North Carolina
- 1971: Ernie Jackson, DB, Duke
- 1972: Steve Jones, RB, Duke
- 1973: Willie Burden, RB, NC State
|
- 1974: Randy White, DT, Maryland
- 1975: Mike Voight, RB, North Carolina
- 1976: Mike Voight, RB, North Carolina
- 1977: Steve Fuller, QB, Clemson
- 1978: Steve Fuller, QB, Clemson
- 1979: Jay Venuto, QB, Wake Forest
- 1980: Lawrence Taylor, LB, North Carolina
- 1981: Jeff Davis, LB, Clemson
- 1982: Chris Castor, WR, Duke
- 1983: Ben Bennett, QB, Duke
- 1984: William Perry, DL, Clemson
- 1985: Barry Word, RB, Virginia
- 1986: Erik Kramer, QB, NC State
- 1987: Michael Perry, DT, Clemson
- 1988: Anthony Dilweg, QB, Duke
- 1989: Clarkston Hines, WR, Duke
- 1990: Shawn Moore, QB, Virginia
- 1991: Matt Blundin, QB, Virginia
- 1992: Charlie Ward, QB, Florida State
- 1993: Charlie Ward, QB, Florida State
- 1994: Robert Baldwin, RB, Duke
|
- 1995: Danny Kanell, QB, Florida State
- 1996: Tiki Barber, RB, Virginia
- 1997: Andre Wadsworth, DE, Florida State
- 1998: Torry Holt, WR, NC State
- 1999: Joe Hamilton, QB, Georgia Tech
- 2000: Chris Weinke, QB, Florida State
- 2001: E. J. Henderson, LB, Maryland
- 2002: Matt Schaub, QB, Virginia
- 2003: Philip Rivers, QB, NC State
- 2004: Bryan Randall, QB, Virginia Tech
- 2005: Chris Barclay, RB, Wake Forest
- 2006: Calvin Johnson, WR, Georgia Tech
- 2007: Matt Ryan, QB, Boston College
- 2008: Jonathan Dwyer, RB, Georgia Tech
- 2009: C. J. Spiller, RB/KR, Clemson
- 2010: Tyrod Taylor, QB, Virginia Tech
- 2011: David Wilson, RB, Virginia Tech
|